Tuesday, March 23, 2010

Book Review Time

Quickly (can I ever do anything quickly on this space?) I'm going to comment on three books I've just read.  The first was Marley & Me by John Grogan - true story from which the movie was created.  Tonya loaned it to me and it is one I recommend heartily - well written, hilarious, and fun!  I loved the dog.  It made me feel a whole lot better about having a hair shedding, hairball vomiting, meower-in-the-middle-of-the-night hanging around.  Unfortunately, Brent hasn't read the book so he still doesn't see it my way.  (Besides, he's the number one champion of our daughters-in-law and really wants them to visit us.)

Next, on recommendation from Leslie, I started reading These is My Words.  This is the book I was going to take with me on vacation and was far enough into it the day we left that the character was rattling around in my head already.  I was far enough into it that I couldn't pack it in advance, just so I could keep reading it right up to the minute we left.

Far enough into it that when we got to the airport and I realized I had left it at home, I wanted to cry.  How could I spend a week away from Sarah?   I was far enough into it to know it was a book I wanted to own.

So I went into a shop at the airport, hoping to find another copy of it to continue.  No luck.  But I did find The Forgotten Garden by Kate Morton, a book that had been heavily recommended by Lisa Jensen, another friend.  In fact, that was the one I was originally planning on purchasing and taking with me, but simply ran out of time to find it before we left.  It was a no brainer.

With the story of Sarah Pine still flavoring even the way I spoke, I settled down and started Forgotten Garden.  As expected, it wasn't long before I was totally engrossed in this new story.  I read it throughout the trip and it became a time-hopping friend to me as Brent dozed away his boredom during long layovers, and as Brent went to his meetings and it was raining outside.  I had almost completed the book by the time we got home, and did turn the last page a couple of days later.   It was a very well written book, taking the reader forward and backward through four generations to solve the mystery of why a little girl was left alone on the docks in Australia.


Then I finally got back into the world of Sarah Pine in These is My Words.  And I finished it yesterday.  Of the three books, I think I liked this one the best.  It's a story I want to read again and again.  I empathized, I cried, I laughed with this sturdy Pioneer woman who helped settle the rough Tucson area (think of Tombstone).  It is based on the life of a real person who lived in the late 1800's, but has been somewhat fictionalized, too.

Anyway, if you like to read and haven't read any of these, I can recommend them all.  Marely would be a G-rated book.  Forgotten Garden I would have to say was an implied PG-13 (limited sexual content;  re: not descriptive but you knew what was happening).  And These...Words would also be a PG-13 (violence).

Lest you think I just love everything I read (which does have a little ring of truth to it) one book I had started but put down after the first chapter was Time Traveler's Wife. I realized it was a little beyond what I care to put into my brain just in the first chapter alone.

Yesterday I started Edgar Sawtelle, on loan to me from Martha at work.  I'll let you know....

3 comments:

Seth and Julie said...

I read "These is my Words" last year for my friends book club. It took me awhile to get in to it, but I ended up really liking it, thanks to Jack. It took me much longer to warm up to Sarah. I haven't read the other two, but I have been trying to check Time Traveller's Wife out for two years from the library and it is always taken. Several people have recommended it...so now I am torn.

Julie L said...

Julie, you may love Time Traveler's Wife. There was an activity described in the first chapter that turned me off. The rest of the book may be just fine. If it happened toward the end of the book I probably wouldn't have thought twice, but experience has shown me that if sexual things are going on early, they only get worse - usually. I may pick it up and try it again later, but right now I'm just not too sure.

Tony and Ann said...

I have to write these down. I usually get to a book store and stare blankly, because I don't remember what anyone told me was good!